NYC’s Carnegie Deli Fans Line up for One Last Sandwich
NEW YORK—After 79 years of serving up heaps of cured meat to tourists, theatre patrons and workaday New Yorkers, the Carnegie Delicatessen will slice its last ridiculously oversized sandwich on Friday.
Fans lined up all week for a last bite at the restaurant, which got a star turn in Woody Allen’s 1984 film Broadway Danny Rose and remained a stop until the end for out-of-towners looking for the classic New York deli experience.
Craig DeGregorio, 38, of Long Island, said he waited for nearly 90 minutes to chow down on its signature dish, a mountainous, $20 pastrami sandwich.
“I figured this was the last chance I was going to get to come here,” he said, adding that the visit was also his first. “I really didn’t mind waiting at all. The sandwich was huge. It took two bites to even make a dent.”
The Carnegie, its walls now lined with photos of celebrities who have eaten there, opened in 1937, drawing its name from Carnegie Hall just a block up 7th Avenue.
Aside from the long lines out on the sidewalk (and unusually high prices), the place screams old New York, from its vintage neon sign, to the items on the menu: slices of cheesecake, knishes, tongue and chopped liver and a $30 Reuben.
Another patron dining in the final days, Donna Nevens, of Elizabeth, N.J., said she wanted to be able to tell her friends she ate at the “world-famous Carnegie deli” at least once.
“It’s a New York institution,” she said, anticipating she’d order a “Woody Allen,” an overstuffed sandwich of half pastrami and half corned beef.
The deli named the sandwich after the director after he filmed key scenes for Broadway Danny Rose there. The deli has also been featured on several television shows, including Law & Order and Dr. Phil.
Although the Carnegie has remained popular with tourists, New Yorkers these days are more likely to go looking for authenticity elsewhere at lower prices. And it’s been a rough few years for the Carnegie.
The restaurant reopened last February after being closed for nearly a year amid an investigation into a possible illegal natural-gas hookup, discovered after a utility crew found a diverted line while they were investigating a leak.
The personal lives of owner Marian Harper and her husband Sandy were thrust into the public spotlight with a messy divorce after she accused him of having an affair with a hostess and slipping her cash and pastrami recipes. The deli was also ordered to pay $2.6 million in back wages to its employees after a labour dispute.
Harper has insisted the closure has nothing to do with any of those issues.
She’s said her long hours at the deli have taken a toll and she wants to take time to enjoy her life. A spokesperson for the deli said in September that Harper would focus on licensing the brand and selling products for wholesale distribution.
The restaurant is scheduled to close at midnight after a last full day of business Friday.
It will still have outposts in Las Vegas, Bethlehem, Penn., Madison Square Garden and at the U.S. Open tennis tournament in Queens.