LeCanadian

Top Menu

  • Login
  • Archives
  • Les Actualités
  • Advertising
  • Sexy Pages
  • Contact Us

Main Menu

  • Home
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Foodie
  • Headline
  • Health
  • Editorials
  • Lifestyle
  • Sports
  • UFO · Exopolitics
  • City
  • Sexuality
  • Dating
Sign in / Join

Login

Welcome! Login in to your account
Lost your password?

Lost Password

Back to login
  • Login
  • Archives
  • Les Actualités
  • Advertising
  • Sexy Pages
  • Contact Us

logo

Header Banner

LeCanadian

  • Home
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Foodie
  • Headline
  • Health
  • Editorials
  • Lifestyle
  • Sports
  • UFO · Exopolitics
  • City
  • Sexuality
  • Dating
  • 7 reasons why online casinos are so popular in Ontario

  • La Commission indépendante soutient le recours de la Cour suprême contre le déni des droits des non-francophones par le Québec

  • Independent Commission endorses Supreme Court of Canada challenge against Quebec’s denial of rights to non-francophones

  • Ottawa International Crafts & Book Expo 2023: An assembly of literary brilliance

  • Diane Descôteaux – Une haïkiste passionnée: Le Salon d’Ottawa

Business
Home›Business›Lawrence Solomon: Electoral Reform Could Curse Canada with a Parliament Full of Trumps

Lawrence Solomon: Electoral Reform Could Curse Canada with a Parliament Full of Trumps

By admin
November 25, 2016
1840
0
Share:

Donald Trump’s surprise win is leading many repulsed Americans to propose the abolition of the Electoral College to prevent a future election of someone they view as a demagogue, a racist or worse. The Trump victory holds many lessons for America but drastic electoral reform isn’t one of them. The U.S. constitution all but guarantees the Electoral College’s endurance.

But there is an electoral lesson here for Canada, with proportional representation a live option to replace our current winner-take-all system. Every Canadian who would fear the attainment of power in our country by a bigoted right-wing populist — or a bigoted left-wing populist, or a fringe movement — should shudder at the thought of exchanging Canada’s sure-footed electoral system for proportional representation, a system with a century-long history of empowering fringe and abhorrent candidates. Europe, largely governed through proportional representation, has long nurtured racist parties that later come to wield power. Israel, with one of the world’s purest proportional representation systems, has for decades denied its citizens public transit on the Sabbath because religious parties — who garner but 10 per cent of the vote — have been able to impose their will on the remaining 90 per cent. Under proportional representation, the tail wags the dog.

Trump’s victory was an anomaly. For the first time in U.S. history, both leading candidates were loathed by the majority of the populace, most of which voted against, rather than for, the choices on offer. In any normal race, Candidate Trump, despite a large, hard-core base numbering tens of millions, would have been drubbed.

In contrast, in a parliamentary system using proportional representation, a party passing a modest threshold, typically five per cent or less of the popular vote, will join the ranks of lawmakers and often be positioned to be a kingmaker. Any party leader amassing as large a share of the populace as Trump had — 30 per cent or more of the vote — would usually be the kingmaker, able to impose policies on the mainstream parties.

Because Trump won the election, if he wishes to he’ll be able to impose policies so many find reprehensible, such as deporting Mexicans or barring Muslim immigrants. But if the U.S. instead had a European-style proportional representation parliament comprised of many parties, including a Democratic party, a Republican party and a Trump-led populist party, Trump would likely have been able to impose some of those policies even if he lost. That is the nature of proportional representation — with no one party holding enough seats to form a government on its own, all are forced to horse-trade with the others in cobbling together coalitions that give coalition members half a loaf rather than none.

In Canada’s case, under proportional representation the Conservative party would almost certainly split into social and economic conservative factions; the Liberals and NDP might also see disgruntled factions hive off, and other special-interest parties would arise. The pared-down Conservative and Liberal parties might each then need to woo the social conservatives for support, reluctantly adopting, for example, capital punishment or stringent anti-abortion policies in order to form a government.

Under Canada’s winner-take-all system, the Conservative party had been able to tamp down the demands of social conservatives because they were subsumed within the party. Should the social conservatives have a party of their own, under proportional representation they could hold the whip hand, able to decide which party formed a government and thus able to force on all Canadians their policies, even those without much public support. More threatening still to Canada would be the separatist Bloc Quebecois — the drip-drip-drip of the concessions it would demand holds the potential to slowly destroy Canada.

Winner-take-all electoral systems, ironically, tend to produce governments that are more representative of the population as a whole than proportional representation systems. We see this even with Trump, who is already walking back some of his harder-line policies and becoming more conciliatory. The incentive of a president of all the American people is naturally to seek find common ground, to be a uniter, not a divider. Had Trump been a loser under a system of proportional representation, his incentive would have been the opposite — to press hard-line policies in order to demonstrate his bona fides to his diehard constituents.

A winner-take-all system promotes stability as well as reconciliation; a proportional representation system — akin to perpetual minority government — is inherently unstable, with coalition partners continually jockeying for position, threatening to leave the coalitions if they don’t get their way, and looking for opportunities to trigger early elections. Little wonder that proportional representation countries tend to have short-lived governments, and often no elected government: Proportional representation countries are typically in limbo after elections — the negotiations among the parties as to how to divide the spoils typically take many weeks, often months and sometimes more than a year. During that period of absentee government, countries are rudderless.

Winner-take-all systems, though unparalleled through the centuries in promoting civil liberties and stable government, are far from perfect, especially in Canada where in recent decades our prime ministers have seized power from the party’s grassroots, leaving local MPs toothless. This isn’t a problem with winner-take-all electoral systems, it’s a problem within Canada’s political parties. The solution doesn’t lie in throwing overboard the most successful electoral system the world has ever known; it lies in empowering the political parties’ grassroots.

Lawrence Solomon is policy director for Probe International. He will debate proportional representation with National Post columnist Andrew Coyne at Green Beanery’s “Grounds for Thought” in Toronto on Tuesday, Nov. 29 at 8 pm. LawrenceSolomon@nextcity.com

Read More..

Post Views: 1,958
Previous Article

VR the World: Virtual Reality Delivers Immersive ...

Next Article

Things Aren’t Looking Very Green for Cincinnati

0
Shares
  • 0
  • +
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0

Related articles More from author

  • Business

    Lower Food Costs Help Slow Canada’s Inflation Rate to 1.2 Per Cent in November

    December 23, 2016
    By admin
  • Business

    Three Ways You Can Save Money as a Wedding Guest

    October 24, 2016
    By admin
  • Business

    Disney’s Moana no Match for Frozen Merchandise Might

    December 12, 2016
    By admin
  • Business

    Canadian cannabis producer Canopy Growth borrows $750 million

    March 26, 2021
    By admin
  • Business

    Bitcoin, rival cryptocurrencies tumble as investors retreat to less risky investments

    February 6, 2018
    By admin
  • Business

    The Taxation of Tips is a Murky Area for Restaurant Staff and Owners

    May 19, 2016
    By admin

Featured Petition

  • Bell Baker’s John Summers – Stop a Crime Against Humanity – What would his Mother think?
  • John E Summers: Ottawa Lawyer Attacks Motherhood and Civil Rights – Support His Disbarment
  • Stop Ottawa Lawyer John Summers’, Marcella Carby-Samuels’ & David Tenenbaum’s Ab
  • Week
  • Month

Week

Sorry. No data so far.

Month

  • 7 reasons why online casi... In the ever-evolving landscape of entertainment and lei...

Popular on The Le Canadian

  1. The Independent Canadian Commission on Civil and Human Rights
  2. AgoraCosmopolitan
  3. Ottawa Market
  4. Agora Publishing Consortium
  5. Le Journal Canadien
  6. Dominion: Food News
  7. LeCanadian.com
  8. The Ottawa Star
  9. Capitalistocracy.com
  10. Agora Books Author House
  11. First Nations Press
  12. The Etiquette Show
  13. Ontario People's Front





Mark's



Recent Posts

  • 7 reasons why online casinos are so popular in Ontario
  • La Commission indépendante soutient le recours de la Cour suprême contre le déni des droits des non-francophones par le Québec
  • Independent Commission endorses Supreme Court of Canada challenge against Quebec’s denial of rights to non-francophones
  • Ottawa International Crafts & Book Expo 2023: An assembly of literary brilliance
  • Diane Descôteaux – Une haïkiste passionnée: Le Salon d’Ottawa
  • Diane Descôteaux – Une haïkiste passionnée: Le Salon d’Ottawa
  • How Canadians can access online casinos through mobile phones
  • Comment gérer un retard de vol ?
  • 5 ways sudoku boosts brain health
  • 10 tips to successfully market your law firm

Most Viewed Posts

  • Automated China –Mass-Producing the Future (61,386)
  • Health: Shampoo Helps Hair Loss Sufferers (57,940)
  • Citizens of Italy unleash mass protests against mandatory vaccination law (39,213)
  • Why Investors are Putting Their Money on High-End Real Estate (37,248)
  • Montréal : le cœur battant de la génération Y (37,092)
  • Une Autre Facette de Richard Lipman : Le Soutien d’un Psychologue à la Fondation Fauna (32,515)
  • Introduction To How And Where You Can Trade CFDs (30,170)
  • Canada’s Property Values Rise, In Spite of Signs of Market Slowdown (21,170)
  • “Not Gonna Write Poems” A Poetry Book by Dr. Michael Lee: Could He Be The Next Shel Silverstein? (17,367)
  • Smoking is Still a Problem in Society – But it’s a Problem That’s Being Addressed (16,166)

Visitors

  • Home
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Foodie
  • Headline
  • Health
  • Editorials
  • Lifestyle
  • Sports
  • UFO · Exopolitics
  • City
  • Sexuality
  • Dating